I’ve had this book on my reading list for the loooongest time, pretty much from the time of release, but I just never got around to reading it because I keep getting put off by the mixed reviews it was receiving. It’s quite clear, from reading all the reviews, that this is the type of book that you’re either going to love or hate. It’s not mediocre. You’ll either find it brilliant or utter crap.
So did I love it, or did I hate it? That is the million dollar question.
The story sucked me in almost immediately and I couldn’t put it down. It was one of those reads that when we had a social engagement or, something else inconvenient like, um, being at work, all I could think about was getting home and getting a few minutes to read more of the book. I was desperate to know what was going to happen. I had all sorts of highfalutin theories over who had taken Amy but I was wrong! So very very wrong.
I don’t want to give too much away for those of you who haven’t read the book but I will say this. I loved Gillian’s writing. It was witty & intelligent and I thought the story was well thought out. It did have me gasping in shock a number of times with the twists and turns that the story took.
Right up until the last page, I was convinced I’d give this book a 5 star rating, it was just that good.
Then I read the last paragraph and found myself figuratively (I was reading on my kindle) flipping between the last page and the acknowledgements thinking… this CAN’T be it? Surely this is NOT how this story is going to end… with such a none end??? Surely not!
Those of you who have read the book, did you also feel the ending was sort of a non-ending? It felt like the last chapter was very rushed and then book just ended abruptly with no proper closure, with no one “winning” (because let’s be honest, the book turned into a who’s going to one up the other). I couldn’t help feeling it was as if the author had gotten bored with the book, or was under a tight deadline and so she wrote the most non-ending ending possible.
That last chapter absolutely ruined the book for me and in the end I can only give it a 2 star rating, because it was well written and well thought out, up until the last paragraph.
Have you read Gone Girl? What did you think?
If you’re keen to read the book and see what all the hype is about, you can buy it here:
Paper back
For Kindle:
Pandora says
I recommended this to you at some point, I think. Despite the ending, what I loved about this book is how angry I was at the end. I hated both Nick and Amy, and I thought they deserved each other. Yes the ending was abrupt, but the rest of the book was unforgettable, and to me, if a book’s name and author stays with me, then it was good, even if was for negative emotions. So many books are forgettable, that often I can’t remember if I read them or not when I see them later again. I won’t forget this book. I read Gillian’s other books too, and though I didn’t find them quite as rivetting, I still found her characters pretty unsympathetic for some reason, but I always needed to know what happens to them. I read that there might be a different ending for the Gone Girl movie, which will be interesting. I love nothing more than a book that I cannot put down. Its not easy to find these amongst all the books out there. I have recommended this book to a lot of people, and like you said, got mixed reactions, but there was always a strong reaction.
Victoria says
I couldn’t agree more with your review of the book, I loved love the book all the way and couldn’t stop telling my husband about the fab book I was reading…
I felt I’d been robbed after reading the last paragraph of the book, it was as if the author didn’t know how to end it.. SO SO disappointing.
I’m definitely going to watch the movie as I’m curious to see how the book translates into film.
Overall I’d give the book a 5/10….
Raylene says
C.a.n.n.o.t finish this book…. It’s so boring I want to rip something in half. Terrible.